PDA

View Full Version : another view of mermaids...



Agaliha
October 1st, 2005, 10:51 PM
Well I was reading up about one of my favorite animals: MANATEES! I think they are sooo cute. They are really gentle sea mammals. And what do you know: they are related to my other favorite animal-- elephants!!

Here is a site with general info: http://www.savethemanatee.org/info.htm

Anyway, as I was reading about them it kept mentioning that way back sailors had mistaken the manatee for mermaids. Now if you look at a manatee-- it's kinda hard to believe, but so many sites and books mention it. So it made me wonder. Note their order too "sirenia"....

Here is some info and sites that mention it:

"This group of solely aquatic mammals, known scientifically as the Sirenia, is unrelated to whales and dolphins. The scientific name comes from the sirens, the mythical sea nymphs who lured lovesick sailors to watery graves, because some historians believe that sailors reporting mermaid sightings actually saw manatees. Indeed, they have no hind legs, and they do have a flipper-like tail vaguely resembling a mermaid's. But they also have a blimp-shaped body and a pair of paddles for front legs. A sailor would have to have been at sea for a long time to mistake a "sea cow" for anything resembling a beautiful woman with long tresses." (http://www.uga.edu/srel/ecoview3-6-05.htm)

What is the sea animal which has given rise to the legends and myths about mermaids?
Probably the best of several theories which have been proposed as explanations of the mermaid myths involves the manatees of the tropical western Atlantic and west coast of Africa and the dugong from Oriental and Australian shores. The manatee is a large marine mammal which lives in shallow bays in some areas along tropical American coasts. From a distance, a manatee might be confused with a swimming human, although all similarity disappears at close range. The body of the manatee is covered with fine wrinkles and is hairless except for the strong bristles which cover the two cleft lobes of the upper lip. The body ends in a broad, shovel-like, horizontal tail with rounded edges. The dugong is very like the manatee except that the tail is forked. The mermaid stories became prevalent in Europe about the time of the early Portugese explorations along the West African Coast and it is supposed that they were based on sightings of these animals in the shallow bays which the ships visited.
(http://www.rsmas.miami.edu/support/lib/seas/seasQA/QAs/m/manatees.html#number4)

Factoid: Manatees were once mistaken for mermaids by sailors.
(http://www.npca.org/marine_and_coastal/marine_wildlife/manatee.asp)

The folklore of the sea contains many references to the sighting of mermaids. The consensus of modern opinion however is that such sightings were of the manatee, one of four species of sea cow belonging to the order Sirenia.
(http://www.bahamaswildlife.fsnet.co.uk/manatee.htm)


Anyway, I just wanted to share this view of mermaids.

Mithrea
October 1st, 2005, 10:58 PM
I've heard this before. Thanks for sharing the info! :)

Silver Water
October 2nd, 2005, 12:10 AM
I've heard this theory many times, and even used it once in a project on Manatees for school several years ago. But, despite all the books and shows and people that say it, I find myself disbelieving it. I've seen a manatee, and even in the water it's hard to imagine them as being compared to anything with a human torso, much less a human female torso. It could be true, of course, I just don't think it is no matter how many different articles and viewpoints I see on it.

Aidron
October 2nd, 2005, 12:12 AM
I have heard this for years and I too find it a bit hard to swallow. The tail of a manitee looks only remotely similar to that of mermaids if you ask me and unless all mermaids look like the proverbial sea cow, it's just a bit too much of a stretch.

Then again, perhaps the sailors all had ocean madness. [smirks]

Agaliha
October 2nd, 2005, 12:28 AM
Then again, perhaps the sailors all had ocean madness. [smirks]

Well actually that is what I read as well. That they were at sea for so long and a little crazy...and away from women for a long time. Maybe wishful thinking? Who knows.


If you have torrential seas and violent waves and such and some manatees in the distance, I can believe that they were mistaken.
But not in calm, clear waters you would be able to see that they are not "fish-women". So that is a stretch.

I think it is a possibility, who knows.
I still love manatees regardless. :)

I think a dolphin fin makes more sense-- if it is seen from a distance with some choppy waves and mist. It looks more like the sterotypical mermaid fin that a manatees...

Maybe mermaids are a combo of many things.

Aidron
October 4th, 2005, 02:01 AM
Well actually that is what I read as well. That they were at sea for so long and a little crazy...and away from women for a long time. Maybe wishful thinking? Who knows.


If you have torrential seas and violent waves and such and some manatees in the distance, I can believe that they were mistaken.
But not in calm, clear waters you would be able to see that they are not "fish-women". So that is a stretch.

I think it is a possibility, who knows.
I still love manatees regardless. :)

I think a dolphin fin makes more sense-- if it is seen from a distance with some choppy waves and mist. It looks more like the sterotypical mermaid fin that a manatees...

Maybe mermaids are a combo of many things.


Agreed, I think I would be far more likely to confuse a dolphin with a mermaid than a fat, wrinkley manitee whose tail resembles nothing even close to what folklore shows mermaids to be. The tails of mermaids are more similar to the shape of dolphins, while Manitees are more rounded.

Then again, mermaids reportedly possess obvious scales, which neither a dolphin or a manitee possess, so who knows. I still think the comparison is one I will never be able to swallow.

enchancea
October 5th, 2005, 12:32 AM
Interesting, thanks for sharing!

fatimah2001
October 5th, 2005, 05:53 PM
has anyone ever seen a mermaid? i would love to see one.
but not that other kind of mermaid though!
u know the ones with the fish heads and human legs!

Agaliha
October 5th, 2005, 09:31 PM
No, I have not seen a mermaid.

Though I would LOVE to see a manatee!