View Poll Results: What form of blood sacrifice would you do?

Voters
357. You may not vote on this poll
  • Sacrifice an animal, and offer it's lifeblood

    18 5.04%
  • offer soem of your own lifeblood

    252 70.59%
  • Sacrifice another Human being

    6 1.68%
  • Decline, and possibly suffer the wrath of your God

    81 22.69%
Page 6 of 21 FirstFirst ... 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 16 ... LastLast
Results 51 to 60 of 204

Thread: Blood sacrifice

  1. #51
    Join Date
    Dec 2003
    Location
    far, far away
    Posts
    606
    In my years on my path, I have offered my own blood, as well as the blood of animals. Blood and meat was left as an offering, and the rest was given to community Elders for food for the winter-the animals were deer, moose, elk, rabbits, and various birds.

    In my mind, offering a blood sacrifice is an integral part of hunting, which I do to feed my family. I also believe that what is not offered must be used, so hides, feathers, bones, meat, is all used.

    As for Monk's question of human sacrifice, that is a simple no, I wouldn't do it, much for the same reasons as Morag.

  2. #52
    Join Date
    Jan 2003
    Posts
    4,905
    Quote Originally Posted by M˛rag Elasaid MacDh˛mhnaill
    You seem to have this idea in your head that sacrificing an animal automatically means it's wasted, which as I've stated several times it is not.
    So please, stop trying to find ways to subtly belittle me or point out that I'm wrong or bad or whatever your reason for all of the questions.
    I fail to see how asking two questions is in any way belittling you. No one else seemed to be offended by them.

    I'm just genuinely curious about where people who feel directed/guided/demanded of by a god/dess would draw the line when it comes to sacrifice. If that bothers you, that's your problem, not mine. As for the other stuff you wrote - I don't believe I've ever criticized anyone on this forum for eating meat nor have I been a holier-than-thou kind of guy just because I don't, so I have no idea where that comes from.

    Quote Originally Posted by M˛rag Elasaid MacDh˛mhnaill
    If my gods are asking for it, there is a reason, a good reason. The gods have the ability and see comprehend things that we humans can never even begin to imagine. They are going to have a hell of a lot better idea of what is necessary than I am. Part of loving and worshipping my gods is trusting them. And I trust them to not ask me to do something so extreme without a very good reason. I also trust that they will let me know what that reason is should the situation ever arise.
    And this is exactly why I asked the question. What if a person's gods told them they felt a human sacrifice was necessary? If they have a better idea of what's necessary, can see and comprehend things we can't and one places that much trust in them, where does one draw the line?

  3. #53
    Join Date
    Feb 2001
    Age
    65
    Posts
    1,654
    Quote Originally Posted by ~ Monk ~
    And this is exactly why I asked the question. What if a person's gods told them they felt a human sacrifice was necessary? If they have a better idea of what's necessary, can see and comprehend things we can't and one places that much trust in them, where does one draw the line?
    Put this way, the question is meaningless unless you are asking someone whose belief system views religious sacrifice and necessity in in such a way this question would arise. Personally, I can't quite imagine why such a hypothetical would for me.

    The word "sacrifice" and its connotations aren't being perceived in the same way by all the posters in this thread.


    Maggie

  4. #54
    Join Date
    Jan 2003
    Location
    NYC ChefWitch & food psycho
    Age
    50
    Posts
    11,475
    Quote Originally Posted by ~ Monk ~
    Just out of curiousity, for those this applies to - if your God/dess deemed it necessary to sacrifice a human, would you do it?
    I don't think I could bring myself to do it.

    I'd shed some of my own blood, but I couldn't spill another's. I've seen animal sacrifices though, there are santeras in my family.
    "Knowledge without mileage is bullsh*t"... Henry Rollins

    "That moral high horse is a tough perch to stay on"... Me

    "PETA doesn't want stressed animals to be cruelly crowded into sheds, ankle-deep in their own crap, because they don't want any animals to die-ever-and basically think chickens should, in time, gain the right to vote. I don't want animals stressed or crowded or treated cruelly or inhumanely because that makes them probably less delicious"...Anthony Bourdain


    R.I.P. MiLo
    Run free and catch the rabbits
    4/7/96 - 11/30/10

  5. #55
    Join Date
    Jun 2004
    Location
    In the heart of my family...
    Posts
    8,115
    I'm not a new Pagan, but thought I'd add my two bits as well.

    I would never sacrifice blood nor life, if my Deity demanded it.
    I might chose to use blood in a ritual, in that case it would be my own blood. But I never have and I doubt I ever will.
    And I would never in a million lifetimes kill another human being for a sacrifice.

  6. #56
    Join Date
    Oct 2003
    Location
    Pittsburgh
    Posts
    7,792
    Quote Originally Posted by ~ Monk ~
    I fail to see how asking two questions is in any way belittling you. No one else seemed to be offended by them.
    Monk, you were not the only person asking me questions. And yes, some of the questions in this thread have come across in a way that implies anyone who does perform an animal sacrifice is a bad person. That whole part of the post was directed not solely at you, but at everyone. I used your name at the beginning of it because you were the most recent querant and you did have a specific question I wanted to address. I was not offended by your questions, just the tone of some people's posts.

    I'm just genuinely curious about where people who feel directed/guided/demanded of by a god/dess would draw the line when it comes to sacrifice. If that bothers you, that's your problem, not mine.
    It's one thing to question a person out of curiousity, it's another thing to do it in a way that comes across as questioning a persons motives. As I said above, the point was directed to everyone, not just in this thread, who has questioned me in such a fashion.

    As for the other stuff you wrote - I don't believe I've ever criticized anyone on this forum for eating meat nor have I been a holier-than-thou kind of guy just because I don't, so I have no idea where that comes from.
    Not specific to you. It's more specific to the people who say they couldn't do it because they can't take a life. They take a life everytime they eat a salad was all I was getting at. It gets very frustrating to hear the same comment again and again, and the way people proclaim, "it's just wrong" gets old. I was trying to get people to think before making statements that have far more meaning then they realize.

    And this is exactly why I asked the question. What if a person's gods told them they felt a human sacrifice was necessary? If they have a better idea of what's necessary, can see and comprehend things we can't and one places that much trust in them, where does one draw the line?
    While I trust my gods implicitly to make the right decisions, I also trust that they know my mind and heart well enough to know what I can and can't do for them. They know that I can't perform an animal sacrifice myself as I'm not properly trained for it, but would if I was trained and it was asked. They also know that I am a product of my culture and could not perform a human sacrifice, not only because of lack of skill and that I find it morally wrong, but also because of the legal issues.

  7. #57
    Join Date
    Jan 2003
    Posts
    4,905
    Quote Originally Posted by M˛rag Elasaid MacDh˛mhnaill
    Monk, you were not the only person asking me questions. And yes, some of the questions in this thread have come across in a way that implies anyone who does perform an animal sacrifice is a bad person. That whole part of the post was directed not solely at you, but at everyone. I used your name at the beginning of it because you were the most recent querant and you did have a specific question I wanted to address.
    I see. I apologize for my misperception.

  8. #58
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Location
    Somewhere on the dork side...
    Age
    36
    Posts
    1,324
    Quote Originally Posted by ~ Monk ~
    Just out of curiousity, for those this applies to - if your God/dess deemed it necessary to sacrifice a human, would you do it?
    Well, this better be a divinity I have a powerful/close working relationship with. And/or the ability to convince me that there is a reason it is needed for me to do so. And of course the matter of the nature of the offering (his/her perception of it) would come into play. Much more likely if we'd been talking to the same god, both were convinced it was worth it, etc. Or, for that matter, if it was a matter of me being the victim (much easier in soooooo many ways. Fewer questions and practical matters to concern myself with being able to deal with.)

    That being said, I don't see it happening. Anything that is big enough for that to be necessary is probably not something that they are going to come talk to me about. If for no other reason than I'm unlikely to be the right sort person to talk to in the right place to do something about it. I may be a tool of the gods, but they are generally skilled enough craftsmen to not use a screwdriver to pry open paint cans. Also, of course, going back to the theme of ill-done sacrifice... I don't know if I am capeable of doing so well, and without the proper offering it still wouldn't be properly done and how many people are really able to make themselves and their lives into an offering such as that?

    I can see it happening as something else. If for some reason I was forced into a position of needing to kill someone (say an attacker, for example) I would try to make it an act of sacrifice... to make the act a sacred one, and to waste as little of it as possible. If someone is going to force me to do something as traumatic and taboo as that, it is going to get used and not just be left hanging and wasted and pointless. Much as I veiw the proper way to hunt. Make a virtue of necessity. If it must be done, make it as well done and as unwasted as possible.
    Last edited by -Ember; February 1st, 2005 at 05:40 PM.
    "The facts do not change, but their order is given another dimension through another myth. They are experienced differently; they gain another tale."-James Hillman

    Justice is blind. A witch is not.

  9. #59
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Location
    Somewhere on the dork side...
    Age
    36
    Posts
    1,324
    Quote Originally Posted by Ravens_Tears
    None of the above.
    And truely in any situation, in my humble opinion, I have no right to "sacrifice" anything but what I truely own. I cannot take from another. I do not have the right.
    But then you have no right to live yourself, for life is dependant upon the taking from others. All that you have is yours from having taken it from others as they took it from still yet others. Yet most of those from who it was taken gave more willingly than we understand, being more inclined to take.

    Is there anything you "truely own"?

    I am willing to take, in appreciation of the gift, and am striving to be ever mindful that I also must give as freely as I have taken.
    "The facts do not change, but their order is given another dimension through another myth. They are experienced differently; they gain another tale."-James Hillman

    Justice is blind. A witch is not.

  10. #60
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Location
    Australia
    Posts
    5,777
    Back when I was on another path I used to offer my own. I dont do it now because I dont believe that I have anyone to offer it to, so I might as well keep it
    "I believe we all suffer under a curse, the curse that we know more than we can bear, and there is nothing, absolutely nothing we can do about the force and lure of this curse." Vittorio -Vittorio the Vampire by Anne Rice

Page 6 of 21 FirstFirst ... 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 16 ... LastLast

Bookmarks

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •